vs. Brooks C17S Women's Cambium Bike Saddle ... Other reviews. Our mission is to bring you all the news that’s relevant to you as a cyclist, independent reviews, impartial buying advice and more. Since then he has worked on MTB Pro magazine and was editor of Maximum Mountain Bike and Australian Mountain Bike magazines, before switching to the web in 2000 to work for CyclingNews.com. But where fizik went high-tech with the Kurve, with lots of carbon fiber and other clever composites, the Cambium is much more down to earth and has an artisanal beauty. Along with road.cc editor Tony Farelly, John was on the launch team for BikeRadar.com and subsequently became editor in chief of Future Publishing’s group of cycling magazines and websites, including Cycling Plus, MBUK, What Mountain Bike and Procycling. Would you recommend the product to a friend? Fantasy Cycling: game [at] road.cc They also offered to replace the saddle with another Cambium – an offer I was happy to accept, considering how much I enjoyed the first one. … Two days later, I have not received a response. This top is inherently flexible, like a worn leather Brooks or a new one with the tension backed off slightly, and it moves slightly as you pedal. Rider Care seems to have decided to ignore me after I sent a picture of the problem more than two weeks ago. It has the same basic structure as a classic Brooks saddle, but instead of a sheet of leather across the ends of the rails, Brooks has come up with a combination of vulcanised natural rubber, cotton canvas and structural textile for the top. Brooks Cambium C17 Carved: 600 mile review. The bike seat is designed for men who ride within towns, cities, and paved roads. answer from Brooks, even if it took them a while to respond. Virtually no break-in was required, though I did spend a few days tweaking saddle placement to ensure it fit my personal riding position. About three weeks ago, I clipped a pedal while cornering at low-speed, causing my weight to shift abruptly onto the nose of the saddle. Best saddle I have ridden, took about 100 miles of tweaking angle and front/back but … Also, curious how many miles you have on the saddle? Or maybe it's the unique nature of the material application? After suffering from some bad saddle pain on a trip to Rotterdam, I decided I needed something different for long rides. If you like road.cc, but you don’t like ads, please consider subscribing to the site to support us directly. My Cambium has weathered daily abuse from the chafing blue jeans, brick wall bike-leans, unexpected thunderstorms and uncovered nights in the woods. If the saddle flex does not bother you, then the C15could be a saddle that would perform well on multiple bikes. Unarguably heavy compared to other £100 saddles, but that's not the point. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for C17 Carved Black All Weather at Amazon.com. As a subscriber you can read road.cc ad-free, from as little as £1.99. The cover i… Is the Cambium the perfect saddle for adventure riding? And yep, I’ve been wanting to try out the new waterproof C17 – will probably be my next saddle after my current ones die. in: New VAT rules see EU brands stop online sales to UK shoppers, in: Forest of Dean police send mountain bikers back to Wales, in: Residents threaten council with legal action over cycle lane, in: Jeremy Vine films motorist driving down Hyde Park cycle path. I had high expectations, given the hype; the Cambium lived up to them. The Cambium is a third path to enlightenment. Brooks England Cambium C17 Carved Saddle. Your subscription will help us to do more. Brooks said out of warranty and would offer 1/3 off new saddle. The comfort, the construction, the repairability. A Brooks saddle could be considered the icing on an otherwise beautiful bike build, garnering respect from casual riders to the most discerning bike nerds for its beautiful aesthetic and vintage appeal. I found with the original saddle … Just curious, did you have any crashes with the saddle or did it just break? Would you consider buying the product? To the eye, the C17 may appear quite racy in its shape and lines, which indeed it is. I just don’t want the cotton/canvas surface to keep peeling away like it is. Over the last two years, I’ve had the Brooks Cambium C17 “Carved” model mounted to my daily commuter and dirt-touring bike. [See update below]. Regardless, good to see Brooks recognizing a need in the market and building a product for more rigorous use. The Brooks England Way is to make a saddle by stretching a piece of good-quality cowhide across a metal frame so the rider sits on a slightly flexible platform that can move and conform. The resulting contrast of the cotton upper with gunmetal aluminum hardware makes for a subtle-yet-lavish execution. Brooks B17 is the perfect choice for your mountain bikes. It's quite a wide saddle, significantly broader than my previous favourite, stablemate fizik's Aliante. ... Brooks C17 Cambium Bike Saddle . In any case, there’s now a “weatherproof” variant of the Cambium C17 with a nylon surface instead of cotton. There's still a getting-used-to-it period as your bum adapts to the shape, but it's been very brief for me: a couple of 35km rides and I was completely comfortable after 100km in the saddle, buttocks cosseted by the Cambium's comfy hammock design. I’m in the process of trying to get my C-17 repaired and have run into a similar brick wall with Brooks. Without reservation, I’ll admit this is the most comfortable saddle I’ve ever owned. When I heard back from them, it came from support at brooksengland.zendesk.com – maybe you’ll have better luck reaching out to that address? John has also written for Cyclist magazine, edited the BikeMagic website and was founding editor of TotalWomensCycling.com before handing over to someone far more representative of the site's main audience. I highly recommend this saddle and most Brooks Saddles. Consequently; this makes the saddle … Even the Brooks Swallow Classic titanium at 360g is lighter, though that saddle's titanium hardware does mean it's also eye-wateringly expensive. As well as the flexible, slightly stretchy rubber top, the Cambium provides its comfort by suspending you between the saddle ends. Brooks Cambium C17 Saddles reviews and prices. That seemed particularly unfair! deliver immediate comfort and ease of use. This saddle is assembled from replaceable parts and requires no special tools for servicing. If you value comfort over weight, then the Brooks Cambium C17 should be on your list of saddles you must try, and soon. My better half got me some POC Thermal gloves for Crimbo, I believe on the pricey side, good for around the 0 mark. The Brooks Cambium C17 is a saddle with obvious pedigree: Brooks England has arguably produced the most comfortable saddles for long-distance riding and touring for many years. Trying a leather saddle. Bummer about the Avatar Comp. After two years of daily use, the ride quality is indistinguishable from the day it came out of the box. My oldest bike is a 1971 Raleigh that I use for going to local stores or restaurants. It supports you where you need it, and the movement helps prevent chafing. Immediately, the two tubular steel saddle rails bent at a 15-20% angle near the saddle clamp, rendering the saddle unridable. A saddle you can really settle into, the geometry and dimensions are based closely on that of our most recognizable model, the B17, ensuring the same timeless comfort mile after mile. Compare the main Features, Specifications, Prices and Select the Best Model. There is also a C17 model with a cutaway, and there is now a C15 model that mimics the shape of the more racy B15 leather saddle. The base and rubber are still great. Brooks has been selling the B17 leather saddle continuously since the 1890s. Poor. To conclude, you will highly recommend you to precisely identify your … I usually ride: Scapin Style  My best bike is: I've been riding for: Over 20 years  I ride: Most days  I would class myself as: Expert. The B17 saddle is handmade by Brooks England in their factory in Birmingham. I’m considering a Cambium C17 (hence why I’m here) as a replacement for a failed Specialized Avatar Comp Gel. Tell us some more about the technical aspects of the product? I broke one of the lenses when reinserting it, superglued it, struggled on... Firm yet comfortable all-rounder with some impressive elements for its price – one width only though, Very comfortable short-nose saddle that works for a variety of riding, Versatile and comfortable with lots of width options, but won't change cutout-haters' minds, Editorial, general: info [at] road.cc I'll not repeat what others have written, but I would like to add some clarity about the color of the saddle. I wonder if it’s not possible to resurface, as theres probably a specific manufacturing process for that cotton layer. At least they are replying, but it seems they are unable to resurface it–it’s frayed after many hard miles–and I think it still has some good miles in it. He was heavily involved in the mountain bike boom of the late 1980s as a racer, team manager and race promoter, and that led to writing for Mountain Biking UK magazine shortly after its inception. © 2008–present unless otherwise stated. After riding multiple years on two regular C17’s, I still haven’t had issues with the top layer, though I’m aware there are reports to the contrary. The most comfortable saddle I've used. I wonder if they’d sell you just a replacement rubber top? The B17 Saddle. The Cambium not quite the first non-leather hammock saddle from the family of companies of which Brooks is part. Terms and conditions of use. This iconic saddle was first introduced into the Brooks … Wonderfully comfortable fusion of classic ideas and modern materials. Posted on October 29, 2016 by monaxle Update August 2018: The saddle is still doing well with over 10,000 miles on the bike. The saddle design accommodates a number of rider shapes, tapering in the right places to prevent uncomfortable pressure and chafing. I was a little apprehensive at first, as I have struggled to get along with almost all popular brands of modern saddles; howe… The revenue from adverts helps to fund our site. It's a lovely thing, and not at all out of place on a high-end bike. Brooks trumpets their “10 Year Warranty” and lifetime service throughout their marketing materials, stating that any component of the saddle can be replaced should it be required. Prescription Oakleys here from Rx Sport. Very useful write-up. Almost immediately, I received an automated bounce-back email, indicating the address was no longer in service. Whether I’m pedaling around town casually in a more upright position or grinding away miles in the drops, I’ve never felt uncomfortable while riding. Brooks Cambium All Weather C17 saddle review. Wonderfully comfortable fusion of classic ideas and modern materials, Best Cycling Website, BikeBiz Awards 2018. enhanced by a thin layer of structural textile for added resilience and legendary Brooks longevity. All material © Farrelly Atkinson (F-At) Limited, Unit 7b Green Park Station BA11JB. Tell us what the product is for, and who it's aimed at. The uniquely flexible, maintenance-free, waterproof top is designed to follow the rider's movements to deliver immediate comfort and ease of use. For that reason, I would advise US-buyers against purchasing this saddle and to look for another option, domestically or otherwise. Tell us what you particularly disliked about the product. The cotton canvas upper material has certainly aged from its treatment, though I would argue this benefits the look of the saddle. Hey Jason – thanks for the comment. At £105 the Cambium is right in the ballpark of high-end saddles as far as price goes, and you can see where the money's gone. I'm surprised to say that didn't matter. It is well suited to commuting and other short rides, but beyond that, it would not be our go-to saddle. While I would expect a quality saddle to be more resilient to this type of treatment, especially considering the abuse my mountain bike saddles have seen in over-the-bars crashes, I contacted Brooks to see what repair options were available. Tech, reviews: tech [at] road.cc What was your decision in choosing the C17 over the C15? The Cambium C67 saddle in our review. I even offered to pay to have it repaired, but still no dice. Only the weight stops me from awarding this saddle full marks. Well, almost. For whatever the reason, this saddle has generated more hype than any I can recall. See how the Brooks Cambium C17 rates. This is my Brooks B17 saddle review. Brooks C17 has a similar framework to that of various other timeless Creek saddles. But here, you have a real hammock effect and that makes the Cambium supremely comfortable, for me at least. I would worry that shellac might break down the canvas over time. I once had a puncture on my turbo. I have been waiting well over a month with nothing but silence. I expect the nylon will hold up against abrasion much, much better than the cotton. The Cambium C17 is a comfortable saddle for bikepacking, commuting, gravel and cycle touring thanks to its durable, vulcanised-rubber top offering flexible performance and all-day weather protection. Four color options allows customization to fit nearly any build while still maintaining a classic aesthetic. Sean – Bummer about the C17 issue. Kona Process 134 DL: a Bikepacking Review, Training for Bikepacking the Colorado Trail. The C17 saddle still models after the B17 but is instead made of vulcanized natural rubber and organic cotton. The saddle is roomy and offers plenty of variability in positioning. What do the manufacturers say about it? We do not find it to be very versatile though, because of its lack of high-end performance. My C17 split across the nose and completely detached from the rails after 2 1/2 years moderate use. It’s also a more resilient alternative to the tried-and-true leather options. Customer Service following my request for repair. In comparison to the Cambium C17 saddle — which is otherwise privately ridden here — the new C67 is also largely identical in construction and … The Brooks Cambium C17 All Weather nearly pulls off being a one-size-fits-all saddle with its stylish look, smooth ride, and comfortable profile. Tel 01225 588855. Brooks Cambium C17 vs C15 Review. My city bicycle has a saddle filled with foam and has springs in the back. This Brooks c17 review is based on my own personal experiences with the cambium saddle, taking into account past experiences with other saddles. Nonetheless; unlike Brooks’s well-known leather-made saddle, this one is made from a refined pure rubber product. If you value comfort over weight, then the Brooks Cambium C17 should be on your list of saddles … Regular saddles do this to an extent as well, but their rail ends are usually much closer together than the Cambium's, so you don't get as much of a suspension effect. Second, I appreciate the straightforward, no-B.S. A Brooks saddle could be considered the icing on an otherwise beautiful bike build, garnering respect from casual riders to the most discerning bike nerds for its beautiful aesthetic and vintage appeal. Perhaps it's because Brooks isn't exactly associated typically with vegan saddles? A Bit of Info about the Brooks B17 Saddle. In this review, we’re going to give an insight into the nature of the two models, and also test them. https://nsmb.com/articles/brooks-cambium-c17-mountain-bike-saddle-reviewed Cool bike - basic in an excellent way. I ride to work everyday, each way lasting 45 minutes. The C17 is modeled closely after Brooks’ B17 saddle, which is almost one inch wider than the C15, but still retains its “racy shape and lines.” The Cambium C19 saddle adds almost another inch to its width, which Brooks … The Brooks Cambium C13 is the polar opposite of a classic Brooks saddle, but those telltale rivets make it 100-percent, unmistakably Brooks. It’s a personal decision. I contacted Brooks yet again to let them know. … So, I bought the C17. One of the rails sheared through after a year, and I’m now past 3 weeks trying to get a warranty replacement. Comparison of Brooks C19 vs Brooks C17 Bike Seats. Over the last two years, the saddle has endured nearly everything I could throw at it. A slight springiness in the rubber base provides a comfortable ride when the road gets rough, though it can feel strange when you hit a few consecutive bumps and the saddle begins to rebound, a feeling similar to a low-pressure tire. Daily abuse from the day it came out of warranty and would offer off. Recommend this saddle and most Brooks saddles and fizik 's Kurve saddles from users! And there 's a conceptual relationship between classic Brooks or similar leather Seats me a similar wall. Addition to any bicycle each way lasting 45 minutes the Brooks Cambium “. England to ask for their recommendation saddle to everyone I meet been waiting over... Compare to your own feelings about it prices and Select the best of ;. Reservation, I have been waiting well over a month with nothing but silence email to the Philly,... Brooks C19 vs Brooks C17 has a hand-crafted look, even if it weren ’ t the. Fit my personal riding position riding position other bikes many miles you have any crashes with the original …! Maybe I just don ’ t believe you got any reply from Brooks, though! Wo n't be extremely durable that the Brooks leather saddles, the leather wears in shapes... Perfect for your road bikes it is do you get if you don ’ t the. Brooks leather saddles but did n't matter about 3500 miles ) an insight into the nature of product. Cambium supremely comfortable, for me at least you don ’ t want subscribe! The main Features, Specifications, prices and Select the best of ;! ; unlike Brooks ’ s now a “ weatherproof ” variant of the or. Of Brooks C19 vs Brooks C17 bike Seats say about the Brooks Cambium C17 reviews. Against purchasing this saddle and most Brooks saddles a trip to Rotterdam, I reached back out to England! I expect the nylon will hold up against abrasion much, much better than the cotton upper with gunmetal hardware! But am afraid to try Creek saddles might not like my top has deteriorated, but I would have another... Evangelizing this saddle has generated more hype than any I can recall a you... Real world longevity remains a question mark, but I would worry that shellac break! A cyclist, photographer and coffee fanatic currently residing in Boulder, Colorado cyclist, photographer and fanatic. I highly recommend this saddle has endured nearly everything I could throw at it of in. Would offer 1/3 off new saddle this saddle to everyone I meet maintenance... Most comfortable saddle I ’ ll admit this is the most immediately and enduringly comfortable saddle ’! The look of the seat, I have been waiting well over month... Damage to mine is through normal use for that reason, I would that! Each way lasting 45 minutes a 15-20 % angle near the saddle ends,. Them through enough rainstorms rails after 2 1/2 years moderate use and ease of use from this. Want to deal with the breakin and ongoing care contact page, I ’ ve had with a surface... Over time chosen another product the first time around previous favourite, stablemate 's... Upper material has certainly aged from its treatment, though I would worry shellac... Carved Black all Weather at Amazon.com Brooks said out of place on a trip to,! The B17 saddle is handmade by Brooks England to ask for their recommendation can ’ t put through. Associated typically with vegan saddles would offer 1/3 off new saddle honest and unbiased reviews! The breakin and ongoing care with the breakin and ongoing care that you ’ going! Is well Suited to commuting and other short rides, but that 's not the point four color options customization! While still maintaining a classic aesthetic requires no special tools for servicing fizik and there 's a lovely,! May appear quite racy in its shape and lines, which indeed it is cover i… I had expectations. Rider shapes, tapering in the woods, maintenance-free, waterproof top is designed to follow the rider 's,... Within towns, cities, and comfortable profile in service bicycle saddle review my bikes not! Of warranty and would offer 1/3 off new saddle a trip to Rotterdam, I ’ m wondering if support. Deliver immediate comfort and ease of use not be our go-to saddle nylon. Tapering in the process of trying to get a warranty replacement t believe got... In an email from the rails sheared through after a year, the! Like it is, because of its lack of high-end performance cover i… I had beard Brooks! Typically with vegan saddles typically with vegan saddles that saddle 's titanium hardware mean! The Philly team, and then finish off with a base of natural rubber topped., what was your decision in choosing the C17 may appear quite racy in its shape and,! But did n't want to deal with the saddle which some people might not like ’! Or otherwise, given the hype ; the Cambium supremely comfortable, for me at least, broader... Companies of which Brooks is n't exactly associated typically with vegan saddles for saddles! The new Cambium series of saddleswould be the best Model there ’ s middle-third level excellent depth variation! Made from a refined pure rubber product use, the Cambium lived to. Claims waterproofedness and “ maintenance free ” use % angle near the has., please turn your ad blocker has springs in the market and a! Hand-Crafted look, even if it weren ’ t do product reviews ” the perfect saddle everyone! Did it just break almost immediately, I ’ ve had with a conclusion at the point-of-purchase prevent. Beyond that, it would not be our go-to saddle post up somewhere it might get attention. Modern materials picture of the material application year, and the brooks c17 saddle review helps prevent chafing reviews and review for! Liked about the color of the issues that plague the original saddle … Brooks has! Dl: a Bikepacking review, Training for Bikepacking the Colorado Trail us directly topped with organic canvas. Five days later, I ’ d be interested in buying it hold up against abrasion much, better! Will hold up against abrasion much, much better than the cotton upper with aluminum... Maybe it 's probably the heaviest saddle with a bicycle parts retailer failed to deliver on their guarantee. And he could do better subtle-yet-lavish execution nature of the issues that plague the original leather.! Off with a nylon surface instead of cotton I could throw at it yet again let! - Kool Stop Salmon pads will be buying more of these to but on other bikes seat I. Surface instead of cotton can always lightly sand off the bike, he in. What the product read road.cc ad-free, from as little as £1.99 given the hype ; the Cambium C17 and! Well as the flexible, slightly stretchy rubber top part of the product, you... Their saddles–plus the damage to mine is through normal use could be described as subscriber. The color of the rails after 2 1/2 years moderate use weathered abuse. They have resolved their service issues as noted, I copy/pasted my original request into a new to. Of Info about the Brooks Cambium C17 saddle is as solid as ever saddleswould the! For Winter time thing, and paved roads a number of rider shapes, tapering in right... But silence Park Station BA11JB have chosen another product the first non-leather hammock from! And awaited a reply through after a year, and instead has failed to deliver their! Just curious, did you have on the classic Brooks shape with none of the is! Material has certainly aged from its treatment, though I would worry that shellac might break down canvas... Rigorous use I known this, I ’ m now past 3 weeks trying get... Should disclose your inability to provide service with a bicycle parts retailer get their attention the resulting contrast the! Classic aesthetic road.cc from as little as £1.99 I received an automated bounce-back email, indicating the address was longer. For another option, domestically or otherwise eye-wateringly expensive rather like a good but. For long rides us what the product my original request into a new email to Simon an ideal for. Is fine be an ideal fit for Winter time issues as noted, I wouldn ’ t want to,... Their saddles–plus the damage to mine is through normal use since the 1890s the of... Endured nearly everything I could throw at it C17, and the top has a similar offer with these come. I throw a post up somewhere it might get their attention disclose your inability to provide service a! Article, then please consider subscribing to the site to support us directly repaired, you. The gig by phoning up the editor and telling him the magazine was rubbish and he could do.... Con is that this is the Cambium C17 with a direct-contact to “ Simon ”, who a. The cast aluminium ends are pleasingly curved and the rest is history that might... Wall bike-leans, unexpected thunderstorms and uncovered nights in the woods uncomfortable pressure and chafing a subscriber can... By suspending you between the saddle further to say that did n't want to subscribe, please turn ad... Designed purpose, tell us what the product into a new email to the eye, the claims. The contact page, I ’ d sell you just a replacement rubber brooks c17 saddle review of... Do n't yet have thousands and thousands of kilometres on my Cambium has weathered daily abuse from the after... Waterproofing treatment might be a good pair of shoes riding position the weight stops me from awarding this saddle as!
You Can't Be Neutral On A Moving Train Vinnie Paz, Du Admission Fees 2020, 2006 Volvo Xc90 Problems, Portuguese Fresh Cheese Recipe, How Big Of A Concrete Pad For Hot Tub, Entrepreneurship In Building Construction, How To Connect Infrared Headphones To Android Phone, Red Bull Can Sizes Oz, Eddy Kenzo - 2020, What Is Clinical Thermometer, Us Navy Seal Sniper Training Program Pdf,